As August and I discovered last year, the most effective way to win an argument is simply to mimic, in an inaccurately high-pitched voice, whatever your opponent has just finished saying. Is that’s only moderately successful, you should probably add effeminate hand gestures, too. Example:
OPPONENT: I’m afraid your position on the role of the Delian League in the Peloponnesian War is grossly overstated and rejected by all leading scholars in the field.
YOU: (Flailing limp wrists and prancing around the room) I’m afraid your position on the role of the Delian League in the Peloponnesian War is grossly overstated and rejected by leading scholars in the field and I’m a huge homo nerd and love to touch my genitals with pliers, wah-wah-wah. Look at me, I’m a baby and I like to whine about everything and hide my contributions to pederasty advocacy groups. Look at me, everybody, I’m an huge fucking idiotface.
Oh yes, start ad libbing insults about the person’s intelligence and sexual orientation once you get the ball rolling. Not only will you win the argument, you’ll also humiliate your adversary, and, don’t hide that smile, it feels so damn good to be rocking at the top of the social ladder. This tactic works so well, in fact, that even if you’re belligerent and completely unfamiliar with the topic of conversation, you will still trounce anyone who tries to correct you on anything.
I developed the thematic basis for this approach in my early high school years when, to the suppressed frustration of a given person a room, I played The Narration Game. This activity would commence by focusing on the given person, we’ll just call him Jayden, and narrating his every action in the most flippant and demeaning way possible. This, by the way, is exceptionally gratifying for anyone who enjoyed agitating others via “copying” but was outwitted when the copy-ee ended the fun by refusing to speak. Here, on the other hand, Jayden’s silence is a new opportunity for mirth. “Look at me, my name is Jayden, I’m not going to talk. Nope, no talking, just sitting. Hmm, I think I’ll show everyone how mature I am by ignoring Dave. I am so mature, because there’s no talking, no talking for me. Just sitting … and scratching my neck. Ooo, man, that was big itch. Woweee. Boy, do I love a good scratch. Ahhh, so much better…”
While this may be the most obnoxious act I’ve ever practiced on a regular to basis to get attention, Jayden has only my parents to blame. They, I’m assuming, named me David knowing full well that people would sing “Daveeeeeeey, Davey Crockett, king of the wild frontier” to me whenever they learned (and confirmed through secret order) the rarity of my first name. Or maybe, (Bible reference!), my parents thought I wouldn’t ever kill a urinating Israeli in a cave. Anyway, this was ridiculous, because its not like they were getting outright cruel and calling me Josh Blue or something. But come on, this is fucking Davey Crockett. He built Tennessee without his shirt and maimed some assholes when he could have killed them as everyone watched him do it.
This confusion I felt about the nature of the insult reminds me of an experience I had at the grocery store last week. Specifically, I was in the deli section looking at exotic cheeses and thinking about how impressed I would be if they had a wart hog in the display case instead of a shitty old farm pig. Anyway, this couple walks up beside me and begins to discuss, among other things, their meat selection.. “Look, honey,” the man said, gesturing at a black store employee. “I didn’t know Martin Luther King Jr. was going to be here.”